There are elements of life that seem so much better in theory than in reality: New Star Wars movies. Pizza buffets. Bill Belichick coaching college football. And now … Shedeur Sanders playing quarterback in the NFL.
You know Shedeur, the most heralded, most successful quarterback of the 2025 rookie class … or, at least, he would be if the NFL hadn’t conspired to send him plummeting to the fifth round of this year’s draft. Or, wait … maybe he’s an entitled nepo baby who only thrived in Colorado because he threw to a Heisman winner and his father was the coach. Is that it?
Advertisement
One player, multiple narratives. All of which can exist forever in the minds of the faithful or the furious … as long as there’s no evidence to swing the argument one way or the other.
Fortunately (or unfortunately) for Sanders, the moment of truth has arrived. This weekend against Las Vegas, Shedeur Sanders will get his first NFL start. And everyone will get to see whether the Hype Train or the Hate Train was the right one to board.
Welcome, friends, to the Shedeur Sanders “I Told You So” Bowl!
Sanders saw his first NFL action last week, coming in to play the second half against Baltimore after starter Dillon Gabriel suffered a concussion. Sanders did not exactly light up the box score, going 4-for-16 for 47 yards with an interception while suffering two sacks. Still, the debut of the son of an NFL immortal was enough to warrant an “every throw” compilation from the NFL’s social media team:
You don’t need to be a grizzled tape-eater to see the problems with Sanders’ debut: lack of timing with the first-team offense, slow progression through his receivers, a throwing motion you could clock with a sun dial. Every snap, Sanders had the look of the guy at the beach who charged out into the ocean … and just realized the waves are much bigger than he’d expected.
Advertisement
Is this correctable in the course of one week of reps with the first team? Maybe yes, probably not, but at least we’re getting the chance to see what Sanders has to offer at the NFL level. And he’s getting the chance to see what an NFL defense — or whatever facsimile of an NFL defense the 2-8 Raiders can manage — looks like over the course of 60 minutes.
“I’m doing everything I need to prepare to be the best version of myself as possible,” Sanders said . “With the circumstances, everything got me sped up, and that’s great. I like pressure in life. I’m just excited for everything. So, I feel like I’m the guy, I know I’m the guy, but you just have to be able to see. The game got to speak.”
The Shedeur Sanders Discourse is the latest iteration of the He Got Robbed mania that swirls around a quarterback every few years — i.e. long enough for everyone to forget we’ve all done this dance before. Back in the early 2010s, there was a “the NFL is keeping Tim Tebow out of the league because of his beliefs!” conspiracy. (Untrue, Tebow is a good man but a bad NFL-level quarterback.) And then in the late 2010s, there was a “the NFL is keeping Colin Kaepernick out of the league because of his protests” conspiracy. (Likely true the first season, untrue afterward as his skills markedly and understandably declined.) It’s always easier to believe in fantastic possibilities rather than face hard realities.
Now, you want a real conspiracy theory, here’s one I totally believe. The NFL looked at this miserable slate of afternoon games — Jags-Cardinals, Falcons-Saints, Browns-Raiders — and decided there had to be at least something worthwhile alongside Eagles-Cowboys. Did the NFL instruct the Browns to keep Gabriel on the bench and start Sanders just to inject a tiny bit of life into Sunday afternoon’s games? I’m not saying they did … but I haven’t found any evidence they didn’t, either. I’m just saying you can’t discount the possibility.
Advertisement
(Disclaimer so someone doesn’t howl “fake news”: The NFL did not do this. The preceding paragraph was a joke.)
This weekend’s game will level a verdict on Shedeur Sanders, one way or another. No, we won’t know about Sanders’ potential for NFL stardom — or “bust” status — from this one game. But we will get more data points, trending in one direction or the other.
The game, as Sanders himself said, will speak. One major 2025 NFL narrative will meet its end this weekend … and another will take flight.
